Cyber Insurance Renewal: The Questions to Expect and How to Prepare
Insurers now ask detailed questions about security controls before they quote or renew. Here is what they commonly ask, why accurate answers matter and how to prepare before the form arrives.
Brandon Strangman6 min read
This article is general information. It is not insurance, legal or financial advice. Talk to your broker or insurer about your policy and its requirements.
A few years ago, a cyber insurance application was a short form. Today many insurers send detailed questionnaires about how a business protects itself, and a policy can be refused, priced higher or limited by the answers. If a renewal is on your calendar, this guide explains what to expect and how to prepare without scrambling in the final week.
Why insurers ask
An insurer is judging how likely you are to have a serious claim. Businesses that have basic protections in place, such as multi-factor authentication and working backups, are less likely to suffer a costly incident, so they are easier to cover. The questionnaire is how the insurer tests that.
Questions commonly asked
Every insurer is different, but the same themes come up again and again.
Sign-in and access
- Is multi-factor authentication required for email, remote access and administrator accounts?
- How many people have administrator rights, and are those accounts separate from everyday ones?
- How are passwords managed?
See our guides on MFA and password managers.
Backups and recovery
- Are backups taken regularly, and is at least one copy kept offline or otherwise protected from tampering?
- Have you tested restoring from backup, and when?
- Is there a documented plan for recovering systems?
See the importance of regular data backups.
Patching and software
- Are operating systems and applications updated, and how quickly are critical patches applied?
- Do you run software that the vendor no longer supports? This includes older versions of Windows. See our article on Windows 10 end of support.
Protection and detection
- Is endpoint protection installed on all devices?
- Is email filtering in place?
- Are logs kept and is anyone looking at them?
People and process
- Do staff receive security awareness training?
- Is there a written incident response plan, and does it say who to call?
- Is there a process for verifying changes to payment details? See invoice fraud and business email compromise.
Business details
- What personal and sensitive information do you hold and how many records?
- What is your turnover, and which industries and states do you operate in?
- Do you rely on third-party providers for critical services?
Some insurers also ask whether you align to the Essential Eight and at what maturity level. See our guide for what that does and does not mean.
Why accuracy matters
It is tempting to tick "yes" to everything. Do not. If a claim is made and it turns out that an answer on the form was wrong, the insurer may reduce or refuse the payout, and in serious cases may cancel the policy. Answer based on what is true across the whole business, not just in the head office or on the machines you looked at.
Where something is partly in place, say so and describe it. "MFA on email, not yet on the remote access tool" is a more useful and honest answer than a blanket yes or no. Your broker can often advise how to present it.
How to prepare before the form arrives
- 1. Start early. Begin at least two months before renewal so there is time to fix gaps rather than only describe them.
- 2. Collect evidence. Keep screenshots or reports showing MFA enrolment, backup schedules and test restores, patch status and device protection.
- 3. Find the gaps. Compare last year's answers with reality. Which questions were awkward?
- 4. Fix the high-value items first. MFA on email and administrator accounts, tested and protected backups, and removing unsupported software are the usual priorities.
- 5. Write the incident plan. A one-page plan with phone numbers, roles and where backups are kept goes a long way.
- 6. Check the policy, not just the form. Look at exclusions, waiting periods, sub-limits and what the insurer expects you to do in an incident, such as calling a hotline before engaging anyone else.
- 7. Ask your broker what they need. They will know what your insurer cares about.
What good looks like
You do not need a perfect score. A small business that can say it has MFA on key systems, protected backups it has tested, supported and patched software, trained staff and a basic response plan is in a much stronger position, both for insurance and for an actual incident.
A note on insurance and security
Insurance is a way to handle the financial cost of an incident. It does not prevent one, and it does not restore your reputation or the time lost. Treat it as one part of a plan that also includes sound security.
use renewal as a deadline for a short security review. The preparation you do for the form is the same preparation that makes an incident less likely and less damaging.
If you would like help gathering evidence or closing gaps before your renewal, see our cyber security page or contact us.
Written byBrandon StrangmanNeed Help with Your Business IT?
Ready to implement these strategies? Our expert team at Defy IT can help you build a resilient, secure IT environment tailored to your specific business needs.
Contact Us TodayReading up on cybersecurity? Explore our Cyber Security services