Skip to main content
Cybersecurity

Multi-Factor Authentication for Small Business: What to Turn On First

Multi-factor authentication is the single most useful sign-in control a small business can add. Here is where to start, which methods to prefer and the gaps that catch businesses out.

Brandon Strangman6 min read
Multi-Factor Authentication for Small Business: What to Turn On First

A password on its own is a weak lock. Passwords get reused, guessed, phished and leaked in breaches of services your staff signed up to years ago. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds a second proof of identity, so a stolen password alone is no longer enough to get in.

It is also one of the eight strategies in the ASD's Essential Eight, which is a good indication of how much weight security agencies put on it. This guide covers where a small business should start and the mistakes that leave gaps.

What MFA actually is

MFA asks for two or more different kinds of proof when someone signs in:

  • Something you know, such as a password or PIN.
  • Something you have, such as a phone running an authenticator app, or a hardware security key.
  • Something you are, such as a fingerprint or face scan on a device.

A password plus a code from an app is MFA. Two passwords is not, because both are the same kind of proof.

Where to turn it on first

You will not enable everything in a day, so start with the accounts that cause the most damage if taken over:

  • 1. Email and Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace. Email resets passwords for almost everything else, so a compromised mailbox is a compromised business. It is also where invoice fraud starts. See our guide to invoice fraud and business email compromise.
  • 2. Administrator accounts anywhere. Admin accounts for your tenant, firewall, hosting, domain registrar and backup system need MFA before anyone else's.
  • 3. Remote access. Any VPN, remote desktop gateway or remote support tool exposed to the internet.
  • 4. Finance and payroll. Online banking, accounting software and payroll platforms.
  • 5. Everything else that holds client or staff data, including your CRM, practice-management software and file-sharing services.

Choosing a method

Not all second factors are equal. In rough order of strength:

  • Hardware security keys and passkeys are the strongest common option because they resist phishing. They only work on the real website, so a fake login page cannot capture them.
  • Authenticator apps with number matching, such as Microsoft Authenticator, are a strong everyday choice. Number matching makes you type a number shown on the sign-in screen, which defeats accidental approvals.
  • SMS text codes are better than nothing, but they can be intercepted or redirected through SIM-swap fraud. Use them only where nothing better is offered.

If your provider lets you choose, move people off SMS over time.

The gaps that catch businesses out

"We enabled it, so we are covered"

Check that MFA is actually enforced, not just available. In many tenants it is optional per user, so a handful of people never enrolled. Run a report of who is registered and who is not, and chase the gaps. Old accounts, shared mailboxes that can sign in and service accounts are common blind spots.

Approval fatigue

If an attacker already has a password, they can trigger sign-in prompts repeatedly and hope someone taps Approve to make it stop. Train staff that an unexpected prompt means somebody has their password, and that the right response is to deny it and report it, not approve it. Number matching helps a great deal here.

Phishing that goes around MFA

Some phishing pages sit between the victim and the real login page and relay the code in real time. App-based MFA does not stop this on its own. Phishing-resistant methods such as security keys and passkeys do, which is why they are worth using for administrators and finance staff first.

No plan for lost phones

Staff lose and replace phones. Decide in advance how a person proves who they are and re-enrols, and make sure the process cannot be talked around by someone phoning the helpdesk with a convincing story. Keep recovery codes for critical accounts somewhere safe and offline.

Locking yourself out

Keep at least two administrator accounts able to sign in, one of them an emergency account with a long, unique password stored securely and excluded from the normal sign-in rules. Test it. The aim is that a mistake in a policy cannot lock every admin out of your own tenant.

A simple rollout order

  • 1. List your critical systems and who administers them.
  • 2. Enforce MFA on admin accounts and email first.
  • 3. Roll out to all staff with a short explanation of what they will see and what to do when a prompt is unexpected.
  • 4. Report on enrolment weekly until every account is covered.
  • 5. Review annually: remove old accounts and move the highest-risk users to stronger methods.
Defy IT Recommendation

do not wait for a perfect rollout plan. Switching MFA on for email and administrators this week removes more risk than any other change of the same size.

For a wider set of settings, see our Microsoft 365 security checklist and the Essential Eight guide. If you want to talk through your own setup, our cyber security page explains what we cover, or you can get in touch.

MFAMulti-Factor AuthenticationMicrosoft 365Account SecuritySmall Business Security
Brandon StrangmanWritten byBrandon Strangman
Defy IT

Need Help with Your Business IT?

Ready to implement these strategies? Our expert team at Defy IT can help you build a resilient, secure IT environment tailored to your specific business needs.

Contact Us Today

Reading up on cybersecurity? Explore our Cyber Security services